01 Who’s winning right now
Local 3-pack listings
These three listings capture an estimated 42–44% of all clicks — about 578–605 visits a month.
| Church | Website | Rating | Reviews | CTR (est.) | Visitors/mo (est.) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Charlottesville First United Methodist Church | www.cvillefirstumc.org | 4.6 | 34 | 17.6% | 242 |
| 2 | First Baptist Church Park Street | fbcparkstreet.com | 4.7 | 44 | 15.4% | 212 |
| 3 | Holy Comforter Catholic Church | holycomforterparish.org | 4.5 | 113 | 15.1% | 208 |
Secondary local listings
Every other church in the area shares an estimated 8% of clicks — roughly 110 website visitors per month, combined, from Google Maps listings.
Standard organic results
These first-page results share an estimated 29–44% of clicks — about 399–605 visits a month.
| Title | Address | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Center Church | Charlottesville, VA | https://centercville.com/ |
| 2 | Charlottesville Community Church | Seeking Gospel ... | https://cvillechurch.org/ |
| 3 | THE BEST 10 Churches in CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA | https://www.yelp.com/search?cflt=churches&find_loc=Charlottesv… |
| 4 | Trinity Presbyterian Church | Charlottesville, VA | God is at work | https://www.trinitycville.org/ |
| 5 | St. Thomas Aquinas University Parish - Charlottesville | https://stauva.org/ |
| 6 | St. Paul's Memorial Church | https://www.spmcuva.org/ |
| 7 | The Point Church VA - Charlottesville | https://www.thepointva.com/ |
| 8 | Maple Grove Christian Church | Welcome - Charlottesville | https://www.thegrovecville.org/ |
| 9 | City Church: New Home City - Charlottesville | https://citychurchcville.com/ |
02 The bottom line
If your church is not listed anywhere on the first page of Google, you are competing with every other church in Charlottesville, VA for an estimated 110 website visitors a month. Everyone searching is being handed the same short list — and you are not on it.
03 How to get your church onto the first page
It takes time and it isn’t always easy. But this is a proven, step-by-step process — and the first four steps cost nothing but attention:
- Claim your church’s Google Business Profile, if you haven’t already.
- Make sure your church’s name, address, and details are correct and identical across the top 40 online directories.
- Ask members, regular attendees, and likeminded visitors to leave honest reviews on your Google Business Profile.
- Respond to every review as it comes in.
- Post regular updates about the church to your Google Business Profile.